Service Manager Pay Plans: 2026 Report
How dealership service managers get paid, what you can expect to earn, and what 16.8 million repair orders say about the numbers your plan pays on.
Updated October 27, 2026. Pay figures come from the public sources listed at the bottom. Repair order data covers 871 dealerships, March 2025 to February 2026.
What we found
- Service managers are usually paid a base salary plus a share of the department's gross profit. Many plans add a monthly CSI bonus.
- There's no published standard for the percentage. Posted plans show 3 to 5% of gross.
- The closest federal data puts median pay at $84,420 a year (BLS, May 2025). Job postings average $96,998 in base pay (Indeed, October 2026).
- Repair orders with a digital conversation, meaning texts between the advisor and the customer, brought in $163.96 more in customer pay than those without.
- Stores selling the same brand are far apart. Ford stores at the 75th percentile do $431 per repair order. At the 25th, $275. See the brand table.
Want to know where your store sits? Enter your brand and two numbers. Your rank shows up right here, no email needed.
That email doesn't look right.
How service managers get paid
Short version: a base salary, plus a percentage of what the department makes. Many plans add a CSI bonus on top.
The details are where plans differ. Here are the three structures we found in public pay plans and consultant material.
| Structure | How it works | What to check |
|---|---|---|
| Salary + % of department gross | A base salary plus a commission on the service department's gross profit, paid monthly or quarterly. | Whether it's gross or net, and which accounts count toward the department. |
| Salary + bonus on targets | A base salary plus bonuses for hitting set goals, like gross profit, CSI or effective labor rate. | Whether the bonus is written in the plan or left to the dealer. |
| Salary only | A fixed salary with no variable pay. | You don't share in any growth you create. |
What percentage of gross do service managers get?
Let's start with the awkward part. Nobody publishes a standard percentage for service managers. We looked through trade press, NADA's public material and consultant sites, and found no survey.
Here's what we did find.
- Consultant Sheriff 5-Star puts service management pay at 5 to 8% of labor gross profit. That's the whole pay cost, base included, with a monthly CSI bonus on top.
- A training provider on the DealerElite forum suggested starting a service manager at 3% of gross and working up to 5% (2011).
- A manager at a GM store posted a plan of 5% of gross profit, a small salary and a $500 CSI bonus (DealersEdge, 2005).
- Plans paid on net use higher rates. One assistant service manager reported 9% of net, 10% above a threshold, plus a $1,500 monthly CSI bonus (Chris Collins Inc., 2020).
So the percentage alone tells you very little. What it's applied to matters more. Labor only or parts too? Gross or net?
How much do service managers make?
Depends who you ask. Each source measures something a little different.
| Source | What it measures | Pay |
|---|---|---|
| BLS OEWS, May 2025 | First-line supervisors of mechanics at automobile dealers. The closest federal category, and it includes shop foremen. Counts commissions, not discretionary bonuses. | Median $84,420. Middle half $62,350 to $118,390. |
| Indeed, October 18, 2026 | Advertised base pay in 5,200 automotive service manager job postings from the past 36 months. | Average $96,998. |
| Salary.com, October 1, 2026 | Dealership service manager salary from employer data. Looks like base salary. | Median $120,707. Middle half $107,870 to $132,746. |
| Job Bank Canada, 2023 to 2024 data | "Automotive service manager," grouped with all retail and wholesale trade managers (NOC 60020). Not dealership-specific. | Median $42.74 an hour. |
Job postings mostly show base pay. If you're on a good commission plan, you can earn well above them.
NADA's Dealership Workforce Study has dealership-specific numbers. It's a paid report, so we didn't use it here.
Lane manager or department manager?
"Service manager" covers two jobs. A lane manager still writes repair orders and works the drive, so the pay sits close to a top advisor's. A department manager or service director owns the department's profit and loss. That's the job most commission plans are written for.
In one public manager thread, posters put lane managers at about $80,000 to $100,000 and department managers at about $150,000 to $200,000. That's one thread, so take it as a rough guide.
How CSI changes your pay
In the plans we found, CSI shows up as a monthly bonus. Posted examples range from $500 a month (DealersEdge, 2005) to $1,500 a month (Chris Collins Inc., 2020).
Some plans raise your rate when you hit the target. Others cut your commission when you miss. We couldn't find a public number for how big that cut usually is.
Read your plan before you count CSI as upside. If it only takes money away, the best you can do is avoid the penalty.
Paid on gross or net?
On gross, you're paid on what the department produces. On net, you're paid on what's left after expenses, and you don't control all of them.
It's the pay plan issue managers raise most on public forums. One posted that their best month paid less than usual because of costs nobody told them about.
If you're on net, ask for the list of expenses charged to the department. And ask how a new one gets added.
Run your own numbers
Here's an example. A $36,000 base ($3,000 a month), plus 3% of $2,000,000 in yearly department gross. That's $96,000 a year. If missing CSI costs you 25% of the commission, it drops to $81,000.
Those are example numbers, not a benchmark. Put in yours.
Your annual pay, CSI target hit
What 16.8 million repair orders show
This is the part you won't find anywhere else. It comes from 871 dealerships on Kimoby over 12 months.
Your commission comes from department gross. Gross comes from the work customers approve and from customers who come back. Here's how much those vary.
More conversation, bigger repair orders
Repair orders with a digital conversation averaged $455.08 in customer pay. Without one, $291.12. That's $163.96 more per repair order.
| Messages on the repair order | Repair orders | Customer pay per RO | First-time customers, pay per RO |
|---|---|---|---|
| No conversation | 12,850,294 | $291.12 | Not split out |
| 1 message | 1,377,008 | $346.44 | $220.82 |
| 2 to 3 messages | 1,313,233 | $397.66 | $365.06 |
| 4 or more messages | 1,309,299 | $626.77 | $660.13 |
That's a correlation. Bigger jobs come with more to talk about, so don't read it as cause.
Customers who come back spend more
A customer coming back after 13 months or more spent $549.28 per repair order. Everyone else, $320.76. 625,625 customers came back after a gap like that.
Same brand, very different stores
We only ranked the 833 of the 871 stores with at least 1,000 closed repair orders, so small stores don't skew it. Median customer pay per RO was $317.62. The bottom quarter sat under $240.79 and the top quarter above $427.35.
The gap holds inside each brand too. In the table, the 25th percentile means a quarter of that brand's stores sit below it. The blue bar runs from the 25th to the 75th percentile, and the line is the median.
| Brand | Stores | 25th percentile | Median | 75th percentile | Range, $150 to $1,050 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Porsche | 10 | $789 | $921 | $1,007 | |
| Land Rover | 13 | $710 | $782 | $813 | |
| Mercedes-Benz | 24 | $540 | $696 | $824 | |
| MINI | 19 | $438 | $517 | $585 | |
| BMW | 50 | $436 | $510 | $589 | |
| Volvo | 17 | $440 | $470 | $573 | |
| Audi | 25 | $377 | $423 | $489 | |
| Acura | 20 | $311 | $421 | $517 | |
| Stellantis | 66 | $290 | $388 | $490 | |
| Lexus | 23 | $322 | $383 | $429 | |
| Subaru | 17 | $261 | $353 | $429 | |
| Ford | 109 | $275 | $343 | $431 | |
| Honda | 60 | $271 | $315 | $373 | |
| Nissan | 22 | $231 | $305 | $345 | |
| GM | 91 | $241 | $298 | $427 | |
| Volkswagen | 50 | $234 | $293 | $363 | |
| Toyota | 66 | $240 | $287 | $342 | |
| Mazda | 28 | $241 | $285 | $361 | |
| Kia | 48 | $196 | $259 | $311 | |
| Hyundai | 26 | $224 | $248 | $332 | |
| Mitsubishi | 10 | $192 | $240 | $284 |
Customer pay per repair order, store-level percentiles. GM and Stellantis are grouped at the corporate level. Brands with fewer than 10 qualifying stores aren't listed.
Found your brand? Get your exact rank and what the top quarter is worth to you.
Before you sign a pay plan
Get these answers in writing.
- What counts as gross. Labor only, or parts too? Customer pay, warranty and internal?
- Gross or net. If it's net, which expenses get charged to the department.
- How CSI works. Does it raise your rate, cut your commission, or both?
- When you get paid. Monthly or quarterly, and what happens if you leave mid-quarter.
- How the plan can change, and how much notice you get.
That last one matters. Some stores rewrite a plan after a record month. The clearest public examples come from advisors, not managers. One top advisor at a high-volume import store posted that their pay was cut 30% for earning too much. Another said their plan changed eight times in seventeen years, paying less each time.
Your best protection is being able to show your work. Track customer pay per RO with and without a digital estimate, the time from estimate to approval, and how many lapsed customers came back.
Most DMS reports can't show those numbers, because the conversation with the customer never gets recorded. With Kimoby, you run estimates, photos, approvals, payments and follow-ups from one Dealership Engagement System (DES)™ connected to your DMS, so you can see them.
Pay plans for advisors work differently. Here's how to build one.
Sources and methodology
- US Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics, May 2025. SOC 49-1011, automobile dealers (NAICS 4411). bls.gov
- Indeed, automotive service manager salaries, updated October 18, 2026. indeed.com
- Salary.com, dealership service manager salary, as of October 1, 2026. salary.com
- Job Bank, Government of Canada, automotive service manager wages, 2023 to 2024 data. jobbank.gc.ca
- Sheriff 5-Star Automotive Operating Systems, fixed operations pay plans, undated. fixedoperationsconsulting.com
- DealerElite forum, service and parts manager pay plan, October 22, 2011. dealerelite.net
- DealersEdge forum, service manager pay plans, September 2005. dealersedge.com
- Chris Collins Inc., how service managers can keep their pay plan from changing, June 1, 2020. chriscollinsinc.com
Kimoby repair order data
871 dealership accounts on Kimoby's Service Lane OS that wrote at least one repair order in the 12 months ending February 2026. That's 16,849,842 closed repair orders and 4,436,882 distinct customers. We sell the software that captured this data. These dealerships chose to invest in customer communication, so they probably don't represent all dealerships. Read the numbers as what those stores achieve, not as an industry average.
Messages per repair order
The breakdown covers the 3,999,540 repair orders that carried at least one message. Messages carry no repair order number in the source data, so message counts are tied to a repair order through the customer record. Read the buckets as directional. These are correlations, not controlled experiments. Job size, vehicle age, brand mix and geography aren't controlled for.
Store and brand percentiles
Computed across 833 accounts with at least 1,000 closed repair orders: P10 $196.32, P25 $240.79, median $317.62, P75 $427.35, P90 $560.54. These are store-level percentiles, not averages weighted by repair order volume. A store selling more than one brand lands between its brands' figures.
Returning customers
625,625 customers returned after 13 months or more away, generating 714,259 repair orders at an average of $549.28 in customer pay, against $320.76 for all other repair orders.
Forum examples
Forum examples come from publicly posted pay plans and comment threads. They're self-reported and self-selected. We use them as examples, not as statistics.
© 2026 Kimoby Inc. All rights reserved. Dealership Engagement System (DES)™ is a trademark of Kimoby Inc.
Service manager pay plan questions
How much do service managers make at dealerships?
The closest federal data, for first-line supervisors of mechanics at automobile dealers, puts median pay at $84,420 a year, with the middle half earning $62,350 to $118,390 (BLS, May 2025). Indeed job postings average $96,998 in base pay (October 2026). Managers on strong commission plans can earn well above posted base pay.
What percentage of gross does a service manager get?
There's no published industry standard. Consultant Sheriff 5-Star puts total service management pay at 5 to 8% of labor gross profit. Posted plans describe commissions of about 3 to 5% of gross, and higher rates when the plan pays on net. Always check whether the percentage applies to labor only or parts too.
Do service managers get a CSI bonus?
Often, yes. The sources we found describe a monthly CSI bonus on top of salary and commission, with posted examples of $500 and $1,500 a month. Some plans raise the commission rate when you hit the CSI target or cut it when you miss. Read the plan to see which way yours works.
Is a service manager paid on gross or net?
Either. On gross, your commission follows what the department produces. On net, it follows what's left after expenses charged to the department, some of which you don't control. If your plan pays on net, ask for the list of expenses and how a new one gets added.
What should my salary be if I run the whole service department?
If you own the department's profit and loss, you're in the role most commission plans are written for. The top quarter of the closest federal category earns above $118,390 (BLS, May 2025). One public manager thread put department managers at about $150,000 to $200,000, but that's a single thread. Your percentage and your department's gross decide most of it.
How is a service manager's pay plan different from a service advisor's?
Advisors are usually paid on what they sell, and managers on the whole department's gross. Consultant Sheriff 5-Star benchmarks advisor pay at around 13% of labor gross profit and service management at 5 to 8%. See our guide to building a service advisor pay plan for the advisor side.